Art is Business

Andy Warhol said, “Being good in business is the most fascinating kind of art.” And I could not agree more.

How can artists secure the resources necessary to sustain and express themselves without money?

Admit it.  What is more inspiring that getting paid for your creations?

The idea that a creative mind and a business mind cannot coexist is absolutely absurd.

I challenge a common belief that is not only fundamentally disrespectful but also destructive. Entrepreneurs are creative by nature.

Is it true that some artists struggle with business and marketing? Absolutely.

Why? Some would say because they do not receive a business education.

Well.  I’m not buying that excuse either. Business fundamentals can be learned.  It does not require an innate talent like art.

Just look at the number of entrepreneurs without college degrees and uneducated immigrants who continue to launch successful businesses in the United States.

A very successful businessman once said, “Artists are the most selfish people I know. They do not take responsibility.  Artists hope to be discovered or expect to receive financial support and so they suffer.”

This is a damning generalization but there is a kernel of truth in his statement.

The fact is, art is business and it is not only of great value to collectors it is of great value to communities.  Dollars invested in revitalizing art communities yield significant returns in the economic development.

Real estate values sore where artists colonize. Culture is capital.

Yet the business minded and creatively minded too often blend like oil and water.

So what are artists to do?  Heed Andy Warhol ’s sage perspective.  Examine his successful history.  He intentionally blurred the lines between art and business.

Embrace business.  Take responsibility for your own economic success.  Learn. This will yield financial and therefore creative freedom.

Artists Earning Over $100,000

Artists Earning Over $100,000

I recently received an inquiry from an artist who apparently found ArtistsWhoTHRIVE.com by searching online for “artists earning $100,000.”

This week I also consulted with another artist who asked me, “How did you sell over $100,000 in art in your first year as a full time artist?”

Apparently this is a magical number equaling success for many artists.

I found these inquiries serendipitous and a bit amusing so I knew that I must answer the question this week.

How did I sell over $100,000 of art in my first year as a full time business?

I tell you how I did it.  And I’ll share how other artists that I have coached have done it or who are going to sell over $100,000 of art.

First let me say, obviously how I sell my art will certainly be different from how you sell yours.

But after coaching and consulting artists from across the globe I have noticed that there is a basic formula for success.

1. Successful artists have a very clear and specific goal, a SMART goal.

My goal was to sell over $100,000 of art in my first year in business full time.

Notice the specificity of this statement.  Also note, I did not “earn” over $100,000, I sold or grossed over $100,000 of my art.  In fact, I exceeded this goal by 25%.

2. Successful artists are disciplined and focused.

I got up every day knowing what my goal was and I built and maintained an action plan to keep me focused.

Building an action plan was pretty easy for me as a former project management consultant.  But if this is not your natural skill set you’ll need to get some help.

3. Successful artists have a positive attitude.

This is huge.  It’s very difficult to remain focused without a positive attitude.  And making and selling art can clearly be a daunting task when you’re starting out.  A few pearls of wisdom to ponder.

Thoughts are things.

As you think so shall you become.

Stand guard at the gate to your mind.

If you don’t know where to start, I recommend starting first by:

A. Developing and maintaining a positive attitude.

B. Then define a SMART goal.

C. Take focused action on it every day until you reach it.

Artists Do Not have a Career – They have a Business

Recently I have noticed ads from the San Francisco Art Academy promoting the tag line “Art as Career.”

Throughout art school I was constantly handed references to ones “artistic career.”

When you look at most fine artists’ websites, what do they present?  They proudly display their resume or their CV.  Are they applying for a job?  I don’t think so.

The only time you have a career is when you work for someone else, when you receive a paycheck, a W2.

Fine artists are in business for themselves.  They are entrepreneurs and they embrace that reality or they reject it and struggle. It’s simply a choice.

If you are a fine artist I’m not sure where you can go to pick up a paycheck for your talent.  And if you do you will most likely be changing gigs often.

Unless you trade your talent for its commercial application, like any small business, you’ll need to define your unique value proposition and reach your target market, even if your market is solely galleries and art consultants.

Why do I put such a fine point on artists having a business and not a career? Because until an artist embraces this fundamental reality they will be trapped by an illusive idea of success that they will never get their heads wrapped around.

I understand that this is a fundamental paradigm shift for most artists and our culture.  My own graphic designer gave me crap about putting my title “Artist & CEO” on my company’s business card.  He said, “CEO? That’s too corporate.”  I replied, “Well, I do own a corporation and I am the CEO. This is my legal title.”

I can hear it now.  But I don’t want to “sell out.” What does that really mean? Does anyone really know? The good news is that much more creative and financial freedom can be found through business savvy.

So if you accept this economic reality what do you do?  Start reading books on marketing, educate yourself about finance, taxes, legal issues, and sales.  Learn whereever and whenever you can.  And consider the fact that Steve Jobs of Apple has always considered himself an artist.

If you live near a major city you can start or continue your business education at a Small Business Development Center. They offer free and low cost services.

Sorry they didn’t clue you in art school but they don’t tell doctors or lawyers how to run a practice either.

Why this Artist chose not to License her Images

4.1

Licensing images is typically what an illustrator does, a fine artist, like myself, not so much.

There’s no right or wrong here, these are just two very different business models.

An illustrator is hired to execute someone else’s vision of a subject.  A fine artist is commissioned to execute their vision.

Fine art is a luxury product.  A luxury product is diluted as it becomes more common and less exclusive.

I have chosen not to license my intellectual property for four main reasons.

1.   It would interfere with communicating exclusivity, a requirement for a luxury brand

2.   I have found it to be too much work to explain licensing to inexperienced licensees

3.   It doesn’t pay all that well and I believe in going for the “low hanging fruit”

4.   The three times I did license my images, it was an enormous pain in the *#<!

The last licensee, a small winery, helped themselves to my image and illegally applied it to their poorly designed website and sign walk sign.  Although these applications were specifically prohibited in the contract.

I sued them twice and I won twice.  But this is not the highest or best use of my time and the financial settlement certainly didn’t make up for all the trouble.

If you are thinking of licensing to gain “exposure”, think carefully. Exposure is often over sold to eager artists.

“Exposure” can be translated into the artist giving a lot for a little to nothing in return.

My first of three wine labels sold a lot of wine and it was prominently featured in wine shops on the end caps.

But I did not profit from the winery’s profit.

I realized quickly that if I was going to license my images for wine labels that they should be the labels on my wine, not someone else’s.

My income has come primarily from the sale of my original oil paintings and the Giclée prints that my company manufactures and sells directly.

Licensing can be profitable, but if you are just starting out, tip toe very cautiously into this realm.  And make darn sure that it supports your long term strategic objectives.

Artist’s Contracts are a Sign of Good Faith

sign here pic

“Doing business without a contract is like building a house without a blue print.” Mark Monlux.

It is naïve to think that you don’t need a contract if you are a creative.  If money is changing hands, you’re in business. Therefore, you need a written contract.

Without a written contract the terms are open for interpretation, and too often it’s misinterpretation when it comes to selling art.

“What if I’m doing business with a friend or family member?” Then you need a contract even more to preserve that important relationship if and when an issue arises.

The single most horrific transaction I’ve had in over five years in business was with a “friend.” She turned Psycho as she absurdly ignored terms of the contract she signed.

She actually accepted the commissioned painting, kept it for three months, and then announced that she wanted to return it and have me paint another one, and yet she had damaged it.

It get’s worse but I’ll spare you the details.  I’m not kidding.  You can’t make this stuff up.  Ironically, this crazed “friend/patron” was a frustrated artist who now represents artists.

Without the contract I’m certain that the situation would have deteriorated even further.  With the contract in place my losses were limited to the extend that I had defined them in the agreement.

Make it clear to friends and family that the rules are the same for them.  If they show any resistance don’t do business with them.  It’s not worth the risk.

“Why are artists adverse to contracts?” I think it is simply a lack of confidence because they don’t yet believe they are successful enough to ask for what they want.

This is stinking thinking. If you want others to respect you and your terms you must have a contract.  It’s business 101.

If the other party is reluctant to sign a clear and fair contract then that’s a big red flag waving, “Don’t go down this road!”

Make sure that you discuss each aspect of your agreement before you present the written contract so that there are no big surprises. Communication is a key to success.

One of the best pieces of advice I’ve heard about writing a contract is to outline it as if you are getting married and as if will be getting a divorce.

Some things to spell out include:

  1. When will the work be complete?
  2. Who owns the intellectual property?
  3. What it will cost?
  4. When the money is due?
  5. What form of payment will you accept?
  6. What if payments are late?
  7. What’s the sales tax?
  8. What’s the scope of the work, what’s included and what’s not?
  9. What if the patron doesn’t like it?
  10. What happens if you want to end the contract?  How and when can you?
  11. What if there is a conflict that you can’t resolve?

The Graphic Design Guild’s Annual Pricing and Ethical Guidelines is a great place to start.  But you really need an attorney, who is licensed in your state, to review your contracts.

I use Pre-Paid Legal for this.  I’ve found this service to be so cost effective that I distribute it to artists.

Using contacts is not a sign of mistrust, it’s a sign of good faith and professionalism.  Contracts help preserve relationships by providing a tool to prevent misunderstanding and mitigate conflict.

Asking is Free

LaborNote

You have currency sitting around your studio. In a sense, you may have stacks of money or you can even manufacture it.  How?  What?

Is there a particular good or service that you need, or just want, but you just can’t afford right now?  Maybe it’s graphic design, massage, editing, consulting services, a haircut, or even medical treatment? You get the picture.

Try bartering.  This is an ancient system of exchange that many creative folks still use today.

“Barter is a method of exchange by which goods or services are directly exchanged for other goods or services without using a medium of exchange, such as money.”

When I created my initial business offering for wineries I needed a credible brochure. So I gave painting lessons to the CEO of one of the very top graphic design firms in the US.  He was so happy that he took his lead graphic designer off of a deadline to design my brochure.  The result, I had graphic communications that made my new enterprise look like I’d been a success for years.

My recommendation.  Put this agreement in writing and have each party sign it.  So that there is no room for misunderstanding, spell out:

  1. specifically what you are trading
  2. when it will be delivered
  3. and for what dollar amount

I suggest keeping it simple, for every dollar of good or service you’ll trade a dollar’s worth of your art.

Make sure that you state that each party will treat this transaction with the same level of importance as any other.

What do you need?  Think of one or two things. Then start asking around  your network. Asking is free.

Money and Poetry

Walking down Haight Street this last sunny Saturday I happened upon a Lynn Gentry whose handmade sign read, “Pick a Subject, a price, Get a Poem.”

There were spontaneous patrons of the arts lined up down the street and others watching. I watched him type a poem on his manual typewriter, proof it, and hand it to a young woman in exchange for two dollars.  Profitable?  Maybe with some refined marketing it could be.

The tag line on his business card reads  “It’s about music, not money.” These words are printed on a green background, the color of money, and several hundred dollar bills are pictured on the right side of the card.

“It’s not about money?”  Please. It’s very much about money, and why not? Because if no money was exchanged I doubt he would be focusing on this particular endeavor on a sunny San Francisco Saturday afternoon.

Several months back I attended a packed poetry and wine pairing, a blue ocean strategy. I was introduced to one of the poets by my friend, the Sommelier of the event.

She said to me “There’s no money in poetry.”  I thought.  “Is she joking?  Look around.”

The room was packed with enthusiastic people who paid $55 a head to attend this event and they vowed to return to the next event.  There’s no reason that the poets couldn’t coordinate this for themselves.

Humanity always has, and always will, find value in poetry. And these two quick examples demonstrate that there IS money in poetry. And why shouldn’t there be? Because with money there’s more, time, energy, and focus to make “music.”

A New Paradigm – Artist and Entrepreneur

AWT2

I founded Artists Who THRIVE with a new paradigm, that of the artist as an entrepreneur.  “Artist and entrepreneur?”  Yes, that’s right.  Define your market, own your platform, and keep all of your profits.

I did this very intentionally.  I had ample access to traditional art representation but there was a problem.  I needed to make a living, a good living, quickly.  I just moved to the beach in San Francisco and it’s very expensive here.

So I had a different view.  I wasn’t interested in showing my work.  I was interested in selling it.

The fact is that there are many talented painters, and the art market is oversaturated, so I defined a target market, a passionate “tribe,” and created unique value. I “celebrated” the tribe, the food and wine enthusiasts of a particular ilk.

This is a blue ocean strategy; eliminating the competition by not competing.  Why aren’t you competing?  You’re offering unique value to a targeted market.  And this is a lot more rewarding, profitable, and less exhausting than waiting in line for an art gallery to care more than you do about selling your work.  They can’t and they just won’t.

Let’s take a look at one of my clients, Melissa McDaniel, another dog photographer.  No, that’s not all.  She is a dog photographer who aligns her work with a passionate cause, animal rescue, a distinct market. She leverages the internet and strategic alliances. Melissa has made it much more than just about Melissa.  I advise my artist clients all the time.  It’s not about you, it’s about your collectors.  Make it bigger than you.

Now if you’re thinking, “I like dogs.  I like animal rescue. I’m going to do that.”  My advice?  Did you hear what I just said? The challenge is to create “unique value.”

How do you that?  Who is more unique than you?  Start with your individual passions, values, and your particular creative inclinations.  That is what artists must do.  Then think who you can serve and how.

This is really not new.  Michelangelo, Andy Warhol, and Jackson Pollock all had unique value and a target market.  The art historians just don’t talk about it much because they are historians not market analysts.

So you art Puritans might want to fire roast me at the stake but I say, “Make art for the love of it and for the money.”

Donating Art to Auctions

Dell-HP-3Par-Bidding-War-2

Should artists donate work to auctions?  My answer, generally, is NO.  “Why?  It’s for a good cause and I’ll get all of that exposure.” My answer: That’s nice and not likely.

If it’s for a good cause and that’s your only motivation, that’s great.  That said, there are better ways for you to support that cause than taking precious work out of your inventory and giving it away without the benefit of a tax deduction.  Which is generally what the IRS provides to all of the other individuals and businesses who donate.  As an artist, you are only permitted to deduct the cost of the materials, not the value of the work.

“Well, I can clear away work that isn’t selling.” So if you were hoping for exposure then how would showcasing lesser work help you build your brand?  One very famous auction stopped asking for donations from artists because they complained that the quality of the art donated wasn’t high enough.  Hmmm. I wonder why?

If an art patron really wants to help you gain exposure and they believe in the cause, then they will buy the work from you at full price and donate it themselves.  Then they can take the full tax deduction.  This is what a wine industry entrepreneur did with one of my paintings two months ago.

Even as the “featured artist” at one of the biggest fund raisers in Napa  I received, zero sales, and you guessed it, zero leads.  Why?  Not because of bad positioning by the organizers or a lack of admiration for my work, which was relevant to the venue.  It was because the folks were in eating, drinking, partying, and in schmoozing mode.  Not, art collecting mode.  Although I didn’t gain much, I didn’t loose much. I only donated the limited license of my copyright and not any art.

When you go to the grocery store are you looking for shoes?  No.  Even if they are great shoes? No. You’re not there for shoes.  So selling art isn’t just about targeting your market it’s about their focus when your target them.

Yes. There are exceptions.  Cause marketing is a very effective marketing strategy for the luxury market.  And charity is good.  But that’s not what we are talking about here.  So if you’re donating your art with the hope of generating sales and building your brand, think again.  There are far better, more profitable, ways to market your art.

My Path Might Have Been Different

I recently received an email from a student who attended my last Artists Who THRIVE seminar, sponsored by the Small Business Development Center.

“Had I heard you speak when I was coming out of graduate school, my path might have been different….” Quinne graduated in 1985 with an MFA and his remark is something that I hear all too often.

Too many graduate from art, music, culinary or other schools, with very high hopes. And too many graduate with no plan or concrete guidance. So their hopes are soon set a drift on a raft of flames when the economic reality of food, shelter, and student loans set in.

What they have not been taught, because too many academics resist the notion, is that in order to thrive as creatives they will also be required to be very savvy entrepreneurs.  Why?  Because there are precious few “jobs” for creatives that deliver stable and adequate income, retirement, and health benefits.  Glinda, the Good Witch, is just not coming.

Why don’t they get this guidance from their professors?  My theory: it’s because their professors are, just that, professors.  And they are not facing the same economic realities of a new graduate.  My opinion: these teaching institutions, that are often very expensive, are simply irresponsible.

I’ll never forget when I served as a panelist at UC Berkeley.  The topic: How to make a viable living as an artist?  The tenured professor of the painting department advised the eager audience, “Don’t worry about it.  Just make art.  It will all work out.” Easy for him to say!  That’s complete BULL$$hit!  My fellow panelist, a successful print maker, said to him in front of a large audience.  “F*&#! That!  People are buying art!” In that moment she became my hero and the seeds for Artists Who THRIVE were planted.